Best Store-Bought Pizza Sauce: My Top Picks!

Last modified on March 15th, 2021 at 10:13 pm

PIZZA – the second universal language next to love. As the saying goes, a pizza a day keeps the sadness away. Am I right? 😉 It’s even better when made from scratch too! It serves as a good family time bonding, especially if you have kids. However, trying to replicate authentic pizza sauce from scratch can be quite painstaking. This is where store-bought pizza sauce comes in. The struggle is not finding them, they’re everywhere. It’s deciding which one to get out of what seems like a thousand options to choose from.

What Are The Criteria For A Mouthwatering Pizza Sauce?

criteria for mouthwatering pizza sauce

Ingredients

This is something that is often overlooked when getting anything ready-made. But, it is important to always check what goes into your food. Especially if you have food sensitivities. A lot of manufacturers include cheese bits, vegetable chunks, or added sugar in their pizza sauce.

Flavor / Pizza Style

What pizza style are you trying to make? There are different pizza styles and they have their distinct taste. For example, Italian pizza tastes more herby as they usually have oregano, basil, olive oil, and other herbs and spices. On the other hand, American style pizza is a little on the sweeter side. If you want a little bit of both, go with French-style pizza sauce. They’re mildly sweet and have a light herby flavor to them.

Consistency / Texture

A good pizza sauce has a thick consistency. You definitely don’t want the sauce to be too watery, as it will slide off your dough. The worst part is, it will make your dough mushy instead of crispy. You also want to decide the texture of the sauce. You can either go with a creamy pizza sauce or one with tomato chunks on it. If we think out of the box, can you use pasta sauce for pizza? Read our blog and find out.

The Best Pizza Sauce In The Market Right Now

The Best Pizza Sauce in the Market

Muir Glen Organic Pizza Sauce

It’s on top of our list for a reason, it is one of the healthier options out there. Muir Glen Pizza Sauce is made from all organic ingredients. It is also low in sodium and has no added sugar. It has a rich tomato and herb taste that may not be for those who prefer pizza sauce on the sweeter side.

Sale
Muir Glen, Organic Diced No Salt Added Tomatoes, 14.5 oz (Pack of 12)
  • PIZZA SAUCE: Whole tomatoes are cooked down into a thick pizza sauce with organic extra virgin olive oil, sea salt, onion,...
  • ORGANIC TOMATOES: Grown on organic farms where they are drenched in California sunshine, tomatoes are USDA Certified Organic...
  • EASY MEAL ADDITION: Field to can in 8 hours; store organic canned tomatoes in pantry for easy use when making soups, sauces...

Last update on 2021-06-21 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Pastorelli Pizza Sauce Italian Chef – Currently Unavailable (as of writing)

If you’re looking for a more authentic Italian pizza taste, this is your best bet. This award-winning pizza sauce has been homemade pizza staple for the last 50 years! It’s no surprise it has perfected the formula to a mouthwatering pizza sauce – added cheese, smooth texture, and the perfect consistency. It’s also a healthy option as it is cholesterol, BPA, and gluten-free.

Pastorelli® Pizza Sauce – Original Italian Pizza Sauce made with Imported Extra Virgin Pizza Olive Oil and Pecorino Romano Cheese Shredded – Since 1952 Family Pizza Sauce Recipe – 8 Ounce (Pack of 12)
  • Award Winning Pizza Sauce - Pastorelli Pizza Sauce Italian Chef has been awarded 5 Times Grand Gold Medal for Best...
  • Eatable & Digestible Pizza Sauce Canned - Pizza Sauce is Gluten Free Pizza Sauce, Preservative Free, Corn Syrup Free &...
  • Unleash Your Inner Pizza Chef - Whether you are a Gourmet Chef or Home-Based Little Chef, Pastorelli Pizza Sauce is a...

Last update on 2021-06-21 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Recommended Alternative: Botticelli Premium Italian Pizza Sauce 

Botticelli Premium Italian Pizza Sauce is perfect for your low carb cravings too! It’s savory and is slightly tangy, thanks to its all-natural spices. Botticelli uses Italian tomatoes, extra virgin olive oil, carrots, sea salt, onion and a pinch of garlic and oregano for added depth.

Botticelli Premium Italian Pizza Sauce for Authentic Italian Taste - (Pack of 2) - Made in Italy, Low Carb, Low Sugar, Keto-Friendly Premium Italian Pizza Sauce - 12.3oz
  • BAKE HOMEMADE PIZZA LIKE NEVER BEFORE - We'll bring you Italian pizza right in your kitchen. Enjoy the rich, aromatic and...
  • MADE WITH FRESH AND FINEST INGREDIENTS - Botticelli's pizza sauce is made with fresh Italian tomato sauce for pizza, extra...
  • READY-TO-USE FRESH PIZZA SAUCE - You won't need to create your own sauce from scratch. Our pizza sauce is ready to use with...

Last update on 2021-06-21 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Prego Pizzeria Style Sauce – Currently Unavailable (as of writing)

Prego Pizzeria Style Sauce is the kid’s choice when it comes to ready-made pizza sauce. It’s sweet and has a vibrant red color. The sauce is made from high-quality ingredients, vine-ripened tomatoes. It is also low in fat and is gluten-free, so it’s good for those with dietary restrictions. It may be a little thin for a pasta sauce but nothing that can’t be fixed by a little tomato paste.

Sale
Prego Traditional Pizza Sauce, Traditional, 14 oz
  • Make the pizza flavors you love at home
  • Made with sweet vine-ripened tomatoes and savory herbs and seasonings
  • Gluten Free

Last update on 2021-06-21 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Recommended Alternative: Contadina Original Pizza Squeeze

A pizza sauce that kids absolutely love is the Contadina Original Pizza Squeeze. Although it comes off more as a condiment, being that it’s in a squeeze bottle. It is made from naturally vine-ripened tomatoes and is fat and cholesterol-free. Despite its rich oregano scent, the sauce is actually on the sweeter side. It’s good for pizza, calzones and as a dip.

Sale
Contadina Pizza Sauce Bottle, 15 oz Bottle (Pack of 4)
  • Contadina Pizza Sauce Bottle
  • Pack of 4 - 15 oz bottles
  • Perfect sauce for your homemade pizza

Last update on 2021-06-21 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Contadina Canned Pizza Sauce

Another pizza sauce from Contadina, who’s been in the tomato canning business since the 1900s, is the Contadina Canned Pizza Sauce. It has 0% fat, 0% added sugar and has no artificial flavorings or preservatives. It has a hint of saltiness from the natural sea salt added to it, which makes the natural flavors come out.

Last update on 2021-06-21 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Rao’s Homemade Marinara Sauce 

Want to have a cheat day but don’t want too much of the guilt? Rao’s Homemade Marinara Sauce is another healthy sauce on our list. It is made from all-natural ingredients so it’s ideal for those who follow a specific diet. The well-balanced blend of slowly simmered Italian tomatoes and fresh spices adds another layer of flavor in your pizza.

Last update on 2021-06-21 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Pomi Tomato Sauce – Currently Unavailable (as of writing)

Pomi has been producing high-quality tomato sauce since 1935. And it has been an all-time favorite household staple since. It is made from pure, naturally ripened Italian tomatoes packed in a convenient BPA free aseptic pouch. This tomato sauce is gluten-free, fat-free, and has all-natural ingredients. It’s best used for making pizza since its all-natural flavor blends well with any topping you desire to put on your dough.

Pomi Tomato Sauce, 17.64 Ounce (Pack of 12)
  • 100% natural Italian tomatoes
  • No artificial ingredients
  • Gluten free

Last update on 2021-06-21 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Recommended Alternative: Full Red Fully Prepared Pizza Sauce

Full Red Fully Prepared Pizza Sauce is the top choice when it comes to making New York Style pizza because of its lightly seasoned taste. This is perfect for when you want to add your own flavor or spices when making your homemade pizza. It’s also ideal for those who are into the pizza business as it is versatile enough to go with any kind of topping.

Sale
Full Red Fully Prepared Pizza Sauce #10
  • Tomato Sauce
  • Pizza Sauce
  • Fully Prepared Sauce

Last update on 2021-06-21 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Godfather’s Pizza Sauce

Godfather’s Restaurant Style Pizza Sauce will remind you of the restaurant chain’s signature Italian pizza taste. With over 40 years of experience in its name, this sauce has a perfectly balanced flavor that goes well with anything. Use it as a pizza sauce, dipping sauce, calzones, or even to cook meatballs in. It has no added sugar too, just tomato puree and natural herbs and spices.

Last update on 2021-06-21 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

BARILLA Tomato & Basil and Traditional Pasta Sauce

BARILLA Tomato & Basil and Traditional Pasta Sauce is inspired by authentic Italian flavors. It is made up of finely diced tomatoes, basil, oregano, and 100% extra virgin olive oil. This pasta sauce is usually added to rigatoni or penne pasta, but it goes just as perfect as a pizza sauce too. Spread it on your pizza dough and top with fresh mozzarella cheese and you’ll have premium tasting pizza in the comforts of your home!

BARILLA Premium Pasta Sauce Variety Pack Tomato & Basil and Traditional Tomato, 24 Ounce Jar (Pack of 4) - No Added Sugar, Artificial Colors, Flavors, or Preservatives - Non-GMO, Gluten Free, Kosher
  • BARILLA PREMIUM SAUCE: We're passionate about bringing the best possible sauce to your home; delivering the quality, flavor...
  • BARILLA PREMIUM PASTA SAUCE: Deliciously distinct premium pasta sauce made with NO SUGAR ADDED and quality ingredients, like...
  • PREMIUM INGREDIENTS: Made with 100% Extra Virgin Olive Oil and naturally sweet vine-ripened tomatoes, with NO ADDED SUGAR or...

Last update on 2021-06-21 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Excited for your next Pizza Friday? Now you know which pizza sauces to look for when you go to the store. It’s good to experiment on different flavors and toppings until you find the best one for you. That’s the best part of making homemade pizza, you get to decide everything that goes on it. Always remember, there’s no such thing as “too much” pizza! 😉 

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.