Best Cheese For Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

**Disclosure: We recommend the best products we think would help our audience and all opinions expressed here are our own. This post contains affiliate links that at no additional cost to you, and we may earn a small commission. Read our full privacy policy here.

If you’re a fan of buffalo chicken sandwiches, you know that the cheese plays a crucial role in taking this classic sandwich to the next level. But with so many different types of cheese available, it can be difficult to know which one to choose. In this article, we’ll explore the various types of cheese that work well with buffalo chicken sandwiches and provide tips on how to incorporate them into your next meal.

The Role of Cheese in a Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

Let’s start with the basics. Cheese adds both flavor and texture to a buffalo chicken sandwich. The creamy, tangy flavor of cheese complements the spicy flavor of buffalo sauce, while the melted texture creates a mouthwatering contrast to the crispy chicken. The right cheese can also help balance out the heat of the sauce, making it less overpowering and more enjoyable.

But not all cheeses are created equal when it comes to a buffalo chicken sandwich. Some popular choices include blue cheese, cheddar, and pepper jack. Blue cheese is a classic pairing with buffalo sauce, as its pungent flavor can stand up to the heat. Cheddar provides a milder flavor that still complements the sauce, while pepper jack adds a bit of extra spice. Ultimately, the choice of cheese comes down to personal preference and the desired level of heat in the sandwich.

How to Choose the Right Cheese for Your Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

When choosing cheese for your buffalo chicken sandwich, consider the flavor and consistency of the cheese. You want a cheese that will complement and enhance the flavors of the chicken and sauce without overwhelming them. Additionally, you want a cheese that will melt well and create that perfect, gooey texture.

One great option for a buffalo chicken sandwich is blue cheese. Its tangy flavor pairs perfectly with the spicy buffalo sauce, and its crumbly texture adds a nice contrast to the soft chicken. Another option is cheddar cheese, which provides a milder flavor but still melts well and adds a creamy texture to the sandwich.

It’s also important to consider the type of bread you’re using for your sandwich. A hearty, crusty bread like ciabatta or sourdough can hold up well to the bold flavors and textures of a buffalo chicken sandwich. Alternatively, a softer bread like a brioche bun can add a touch of sweetness and help balance out the spiciness of the sauce.

Top 5 Cheeses to Elevate Your Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

Now that we know what to look for in a cheese, let’s explore some of the best options for a buffalo chicken sandwich:

  • Blue Cheese: This classic cheese is a favorite for buffalo chicken sandwiches. Its pungent flavor adds a bold note to the sandwich, and the crumbly texture creates a nice contrast to the chicken.
  • Cheddar: Cheddar is another popular option that adds a slightly sharp and salty flavor to the sandwich. It’s also a great melting cheese, making it perfect for achieving that ideal cheesy texture.
  • Pepper Jack: For those who like a little extra spice, pepper jack cheese is a great choice. It has a mild, creamy flavor with a subtle kick from the peppers. The melting properties of this cheese also make it wonderful for a sandwich.
  • Mozzarella: Mozzarella is a classic cheese that melts beautifully and has a creamy, mild flavor that won’t detract from the spicy buffalo sauce. Its texture adds a new dimension to the sandwich that is both satisfying and delicious.
  • Gouda: Gouda might not be an obvious choice, but its smoky and nutty flavor makes it a great match for the flavors in a buffalo chicken sandwich. It’s also a great melting cheese with a soft, buttery texture.

When it comes to choosing the perfect cheese for your buffalo chicken sandwich, it’s important to consider the texture as well as the flavor. A cheese that melts well and has a creamy texture can help to balance out the spiciness of the buffalo sauce and create a more satisfying sandwich experience. Additionally, don’t be afraid to experiment with different cheese combinations to find your perfect match!

Cheddar vs Blue Cheese: Which is Better for a Buffalo Chicken Sandwich?

While both cheddar and blue cheese are excellent choices for a buffalo chicken sandwich, it ultimately comes down to personal preference. Do you want a sharper, pungent flavor or a mild, slightly salty flavor? Both cheeses melt well and create a great texture when used on a sandwich, so the choice is yours.

However, there are some additional factors to consider when choosing between cheddar and blue cheese for your buffalo chicken sandwich. Cheddar cheese is a more versatile option and can be used in a variety of dishes, while blue cheese is more commonly associated with buffalo chicken and other spicy dishes.

Another consideration is the nutritional value of each cheese. Cheddar cheese is higher in calories and fat than blue cheese, but it also contains more protein and calcium. Blue cheese, on the other hand, is lower in calories and fat but higher in sodium.

The Creamy Touch: Cream Cheese as a Delicious Alternative

For those who want to switch things up, cream cheese can be a lovely alternative to traditional cheeses. Its creamy, tangy texture complements the buffalo sauce and adds a unique twist to the sandwich. Spread a little cream cheese on your bread before adding the chicken and sauce for a deliciously different take on the classic sandwich.

Not only is cream cheese a great addition to buffalo chicken sandwiches, it can also be used in a variety of other dishes. It can be mixed with herbs and spices to create a flavorful spread for bagels or crackers, or used as a creamy base for dips and sauces. Cream cheese can even be used in baking, adding richness and moisture to cakes and pastries. So next time you’re looking to add a creamy touch to your dish, consider reaching for a block of cream cheese.

Adding a Twist: Pepper Jack Cheese on Your Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

For a little extra kick, consider using pepper jack cheese on your buffalo chicken sandwich. Its mild, creamy flavor is complemented by the slight spiciness of the peppers, creating a tantalizing flavor profile. Plus, the cheese melts beautifully and creates that sought-after gooey texture that everyone loves.

Another great thing about using pepper jack cheese on your buffalo chicken sandwich is that it adds a pop of color. The bright orange and green specks of the peppers in the cheese make the sandwich look even more appetizing. It’s a great way to make your sandwich stand out and look more visually appealing.

But if you’re not a fan of spicy food, don’t worry. You can still enjoy the creaminess of pepper jack cheese without the heat. Simply look for a milder version of the cheese, or mix it with a mild cheddar to tone down the spiciness. Either way, you’ll still get that delicious, gooey texture that makes a buffalo chicken sandwich so satisfying.

The Melting Factor: Mozzarella Cheese for Your Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

If you’re looking for a cheese that will create an oozy, melted texture on your sandwich, mozzarella is a great choice. Its mild flavor won’t compete with the buffalo sauce, and its texture adds a satisfying element to the sandwich. Pile it high on your sandwich for that perfect cheesy melt.

Beyond Basic: Gouda and Havarti Cheeses for a Unique Flavor Profile

If you’re looking for something a little different, consider using gouda or havarti cheese on your buffalo chicken sandwich. Both cheeses have a unique flavor profile that adds depth and complexity to the sandwich. Gouda has a smoky, nutty flavor that pairs well with the spicy sauce, while havarti has a buttery, slightly sweet taste that creates a lovely complement to the heat.

Vegan and Dairy-Free Options for Your Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

If you’re vegan or dairy-free, there are still plenty of options for adding a cheesy element to your buffalo chicken sandwich. Some great plant-based options include vegan cheese shreds, vegan cream cheese, or even a dairy-free cheese sauce. These alternatives can provide that same creamy, tangy flavor and melty texture without any animal products.

Making the Perfect Melt: Tips for Melting Cheese on Your Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

While most cheeses will melt relatively easily on a sandwich, there are a few tips for achieving that perfect, gooey melt. First, make sure your cheese is at room temperature before adding it to the sandwich. Room-temperature cheese melts more evenly and creates a better texture. Second, be patient and give the cheese time to melt. Covering the sandwich while it’s cooking can help speed up the melting process and create that perfect cheesy finish.

Pairing Wine and Cheese with Your Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

If you want to take your buffalo chicken sandwich experience to the next level, consider pairing it with the right cheese and wine. For a blue cheese buffalo chicken sandwich, a bold red wine like a Cabernet Sauvignon can be a great match. For a milder cheese like mozzarella, a crisp white wine like Pinot Grigio can complement the flavors nicely. Play around with different combinations to find the perfect pairing for your taste buds.

The Perfect Side Dishes to Accompany Your Buffalo Chicken Sandwich with Cheese

No sandwich is complete without the perfect side dishes. For a buffalo chicken sandwich with cheese, consider pairing it with some classic sides like potato chips or seasoned fries. For a healthier option, a side salad with a tangy vinaigrette dressing can add a refreshing contrast to the spicy sandwich. You could even add some avocado or bacon as toppings to your salad to create a next-level side dish.

How to Store and Reheat Leftover Buffalo Chicken Sandwiches with Cheese

Leftovers from a buffalo chicken sandwich can be just as delicious the next day, but it’s important to store them properly to maintain the integrity of the cheese. Store your leftovers in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to three days. To reheat, place the sandwich in the oven on a low temperature until the cheese is melted and the chicken is warm again. Alternatively, you can reheat in a skillet on the stovetop, being sure to cover the sandwich with a lid to ensure everything heats evenly.


When it comes to the best cheese for a buffalo chicken sandwich, the possibilities are endless. Whether you want a classic option like blue cheese or cheddar, or you want to mix things up with cream cheese or gouda, there’s a cheese out there that will make your sandwich sing. Remember to consider the flavor and texture of the cheese when making your choice, and don’t be afraid to try something new. With the right cheese and some delicious sides, your next buffalo chicken sandwich could be the best one yet!

Leave a Comment